Feast of the Seven Fishes Ideas: An Easy Christmas Eve Menu

Seven fishes on Christmas Eve sounds wonderful until you count the pans.

If you want feast of the seven fishes ideas that keep the tradition and still get you to the table with everyone else, plan the night around one pot that covers several fishes at once.

Add a couple of classics you can start days ahead, and save a single dish for the last minute.

What is the Feast of the Seven Fishes?

The Feast of the Seven Fishes is an Italian-American Christmas Eve dinner of several fish and seafood dishes. It grew out of a Catholic custom: before the 1960s, Christmas Eve was a day of abstinence from meat ahead of the Christmas feast, so seafood filled the table.

In Italy the night is la Vigilia, the Christmas Eve vigil. Fish that night was mostly a Southern Italian practice, and according to National Geographic, North and Central Italy did not eat fish on Christmas Eve. Immigrants from Southern Italy and Sicily brought the meal to the United States around 1900. Over the next hundred years, Italian-American families turned a simple vigil supper into a big seafood celebration.

The name is mostly an American one. A travel writer who asked friends in Italy about the “Feast of the Seven Fishes” was told they had never heard of it, and Tasting Table traces the earliest written reference to a 1987 New York Times article.

Why seven? The sources disagree

No one has a settled answer, and the explanations conflict:

  • Religious sevens. The seven sacraments and the seven deadly sins come up most often.
  • Creation and Rome. Some point to the seven days of creation or the seven hills of Rome.
  • Other numbers entirely. Some families serve nine, eleven or thirteen fishes. Britannica notes feasts of 3, 11 or 13. Another account describes a twelve-fish version for the apostles and a thirteen-fish version that adds one for Jesus.

Sources also split on what gets counted. Britannica describes seven dishes of fish, while others talk about seven kinds of fish and seafood. The size of the spread has always varied, too; one Italian-American writer recalls that the amount of fish depended on what a family could afford. Your family’s count is the right count.

Classic seven fishes dishes

  • Baccalà (salt cod). Tasting Table calls it and calamari near-universal staples.
  • Calamari, fried or stuffed with breadcrumbs.
  • Fried smelts.
  • Clams, often baked as clams oreganata.
  • Scungilli (conch).
  • Eel, roasted in some households.
  • Shrimp, scallops, mussels and lobster on many modern menus.
  • Anchovies and octopus in plenty of homes.

How to get to seven fishes without seven cooking projects

A traditional spread can mean seven pans, seven timers and a host who misses dinner. The fix is to count fishes, not recipes. Three rules do most of the work:

  1. Let one dish carry several fishes.
  2. Start the slow classics days ahead.
  3. Leave only one dish for the last minute.

Let a seafood steam pot cover several fishes at once

A seafood steam pot is one pot of seafood, sweet corn, red bliss potatoes and butter that you steam together and dump out on the table. If the idea is new to you, here is what a seafood steam pot is and how it works. With Topsail Steamer’s Bay Buckets, you add water or beer, skip the pre-boil and steam for about 40 minutes on the stove.

Here is an honest count of the seafood in the buckets that do the most for a seven fishes table:

Bay Bucket Seafood inside Kinds of seafood Sausage?
Shark Bite lobster, shrimp, snow crab, clams, scallops 5 Yes
Captain Pierce shrimp, snow crab, scallops, clams 4 Yes
Wrightsville snow crab, scallops, shrimp, clams 4 Yes
Miss Emily II shrimp, snow crab, lobster, clams 4 Yes
Crabby Jimbo shrimp, snow crab 2 No

Two notes before you count. Families that count kinds of seafood get five from Shark Bite in one pot. If you count dishes instead, treat a bucket as one course, the centerpiece the rest of the menu builds around. And for a meatless Christmas Eve, check the sausage column: most signature buckets include it, and Crabby Jimbo is the one without it. Or you can build your own pot and exclude the meat.

Start baccalà a few days early

Salt cod has to soak before you cook it. A thick fillet usually needs 48 to 72 hours in the refrigerator, with fresh water about every eight hours, and it should never soak at room temperature. Put it in the fridge a few days before Christmas Eve and most of the work is done before the day arrives. Cook and taste a small piece from the thickest part to check the salt.

Save one fried dish for the end

Fried smelts or fried calamari belong on a lot of Vigilia tables. Frying wants to happen right before serving, so pick one and let it be the only pan going when guests sit down.

Three sample seven fishes menus

  • Five in one pot, three cooking jobs. Shark Bite with lobster, shrimp, snow crab, clams and scallops, plus baccalà salad and fried smelts. That makes seven.
  • Four in one pot, four jobs. Captain Pierce with shrimp, snow crab, scallops and clams, plus baccalà, fried calamari and linguine with anchovies. Seven again.
  • A meatless table. Build your own bucket can get you to three, four, or five fishes, but if you just want a pre-made Steamer pot then get Crabby Jimbo for shrimp and snow crab, plus baccalà, fried calamari, clams oreganata, linguine with anchovies and scungilli salad.

How much to order for Christmas Eve

Bay Buckets come in two sizes: Low Tider feeds 2-3 and High Tider feeds 4-6. On a seven fishes night the bucket shares the table with other courses, so size by headcount and let the extra dishes add cushion. A table of eight could use two High Tiders, or one High Tider and one Low Tider if the other dishes are generous.

Pickup or shipping for your Christmas Eve seafood boil

You have two ways to get a Christmas Eve seafood boil home:

Hosting 20 to 30? A Party Pot feeds that many and is pickup only. Whichever route you pick, order ahead so the centerpiece is not the thing you are waiting on.

Send a seafood boil as a holiday gift

Not everyone gets home for the holidays. A shipped Bay Bucket lets a son in Denver or a sister in Cincinnati join the family’s seven fishes night with a pot on their own table. Browse the seafood boil gift options, or send Topsail Steamer gift cards and let them pick the bucket.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have to serve seven fishes?

No. Plenty of families serve nine, eleven or thirteen fishes, and Britannica notes feasts of three as well. Sources do not agree on why the number is seven, with explanations ranging from the sacraments to the hills of Rome. Some families count seven dishes, others seven kinds of seafood. Pick the count that fits your kitchen and your crowd. A household of four with one oven is better served by five fishes done well than seven done in a panic. If the number matters to your family, count kinds of seafood; one pot can then carry a good share of the total.

Is the Feast of the Seven Fishes Italian or Italian-American?

It is Italian-American, with roots in Southern Italy. In Italy the night is la Vigilia, and eating fish on Christmas Eve was mostly a Southern Italian custom. Immigrants brought it to the United States around 1900, and it grew into the big seafood spread over the following century. The name itself appears to be American: Tasting Table traces its first written use to a 1987 New York Times article. That history is part of why families feel free to adapt the menu. The tradition has been changing since it crossed the ocean.

Can a seafood steam pot count as several of the seven fishes?

Yes, if your family counts kinds of seafood rather than dishes. Topsail Steamer’s Shark Bite Bay Bucket holds lobster, shrimp, snow crab, clams and scallops, five kinds in one pot. Captain Pierce, Wrightsville and Miss Emily II each hold four. The sausage, corn and potatoes do not count toward the fishes. Build your own pot to avoid the meat, and have three-to-five seafood of your choosing. If your family counts dishes, the bucket is one course, but it saves the most work, since it steams in about 40 minutes with no pre-boil. Add two or three classics like baccalà and fried smelts to complete the table.

What seven fishes dishes can you make ahead?

Baccalà comes first, because salt cod needs 48 to 72 hours of refrigerated soaking with fresh water about every eight hours. Start it a few days before Christmas Eve. Cold dishes such as baccalà salad or scungilli salad can be assembled earlier in the day, which frees the stove. Keep the fried dish, like smelts or calamari, for right before serving. The steam pot fits in between: it needs only water or beer and about 40 minutes, so start it before the frying begins and both land on the table close together.

Is a seafood boil a good Christmas Eve dinner?

For a seven fishes table, yes, because it covers several seafood courses in one pot and keeps the host out of the kitchen. A Bay Bucket steams in about 40 minutes with no pre-boil, then dumps out on table paper for a family-style spread. The tradeoff is formality. A seafood boil is hands-on and a little messy, so if your family’s Vigilia is a plated, multi-course affair, serve the steam pot as one course rather than the whole meal. If a relaxed table is the goal, a boil delivers it well.

Is the Feast of the Seven Fishes meatless?

Traditionally, yes. Christmas Eve was a day of abstinence from meat for Catholics before the 1960s, which is why seafood took over the menu. Many families still keep it meatless; others relax the rule. If yours keeps the custom, check what is in the pot. Most Topsail Steamer signature buckets include sausage, while Crabby Jimbo (shrimp, snow crab, potatoes, corn) does not. Build Your Own is an option to select your seafood and leave out the meat. Plan the rest of the menu around the fishes that matter most to your family.

How big a Bay Bucket do I need for Christmas Eve?

A Low Tider feeds 2-3 and a High Tider feeds 4-6. On a seven fishes night the bucket is one of several courses, so size by headcount and let the other dishes add cushion. Six people can share one High Tider plus two or three other dishes. A table of ten has room to spare with two High Tiders. Party Pots are built for 20 to 30 guests. It is pickup only, so it works for families near a Topsail Steamer store. Our full guide covers how much seafood boil per person.

Can I get a seafood boil shipped for Christmas Eve?

Yes. Bay Buckets ship nationwide, so a family without a nearby store can still put a steam pot on the Christmas Eve table. The key is to order ahead, since a centerpiece that shows up late changes the whole menu. Party Pots do not ship; they are pickup only. To send a boil to someone else’s holiday table, the same shipped Bay Buckets work as a gift. Gift cards let the recipient choose the bucket for themselves.

Make this Christmas Eve the easy one

Keep the baccalà, keep the smelts, keep the count that means something to your family. Let one pot carry the rest. Order a Topsail Steamer Bay Bucket for store pickup or nationwide shipping, order ahead, and spend Christmas Eve at the table instead of at the stove.